We come to this place for magic.

Today, as people post their way through their Oscars comedowns, Twitter has basically become a Tommy Wiseau movie set: riddled with bad takes. Will Smith got onstage and slapped Chris Rock in response to a joke Rock made about Jada Pinkett Smith, and now every person online thinks they’re an expert on alopecia, stand-up comedy, interpersonal violence, institutional violence, toxic masculinity, censorship, race, and meme-making. That last one is less of a problem than all the others, especially when it leads to some pretty creative video work. One such meme that’s been floating around the discourse stew is a picture of Nicole Kidman sitting in the audience, eyes agog and arms out, displaying more emotion on her face than we knew was still medically possible. It’s been shared thousands of times with captions saying that it’s a shot of her reaction to the now capital-S Slap.

Nicole Kidman reacting to Will Smith punching Chris Rock is more Lucy than Being the Ricardos. pic.twitter.com/BdFomkE7BZ

— Melissa Murray (@ProfMMurray) March 28, 2022

"The Slap" was so powerful it made Nicole Kidman's face move for the first time in 11 years #Oscars2022 #Oscars #WillAndChris #WillSmith #ChrisRock pic.twitter.com/tR16bzkITt

— Terry Hague (@TezzaBelle88) March 28, 2022

Nicole Kidman finally trading in the seal clap meme for her Will Smith/Chris Rock slap reaction 😭😭😭 #Oscars pic.twitter.com/H84BqMWgAa

— Joe (@onlyjoekin_) March 28, 2022

nicole kidman me representa cuando vi a will smith enojarse pic.twitter.com/jpfbBHvyI6

— ◟ lu | harry’s house (@hrryfairyhabit) March 28, 2022

But here’s the thing: That’s not a picture of Nicole Kidman reacting to the Slap. The photo was taken and posted to Getty Images hours earlier, during the un-televised first hour of the ceremony reserved for craft awards. The photo was already making the rounds by at least 7:34 ET, 26 minutes before the broadcast even began.

WHY ISN'T THIS ON TV pic.twitter.com/Pc963qDu09

— Matt Jacobs (@tarantallegra) March 27, 2022

But if that wasn’t her reaction to an A-lister throwing hands at the most performatively decorous event of the year, then what caused the face-crack? It would have to be something truly major to exhibit such a look of unbridled shock and astonishment … something like …

… Jessica Chastain walking into a room.

Yes. We reached out to the photo’s photographer, Myung Chun of the Los Angeles Times, and asked if he remembered what it was that Kidman was reacting to, and he wrote back, “Yes, the picture of Nicole Kidman was taken during the non-televised portion. It appeared that she was excited to see Jessica Chastain across the room. Kidman then reached out her arms and waved to her with both hands.” We agree that this is the exact right level of excitement with which to greet Jessica Chastain when she enters a space. “Shortly thereafter, Chastain walked over to greet Kidman and her husband Keith Urban,” Chun added.

the category is women kneeling down to nicole kidman #oscars pic.twitter.com/zezwffpulN

— liyah (@NlCOLEKIDWOMAN) March 28, 2022

What a shame that ABC didn’t broadcast the first hour of the ceremony because clearly we missed out on the real biggest moment of the night: Nicole Kidman saying, “Oh, hey.”

This Is Not a Picture of Nicole Kidman Reacting to the Slap

ncG1vNJzZmivp6x7t8HLrayrnV6YvK57kWlpa2dgaHyvtcKoo55lm56xrq3NZq6ipJxiwK6106Fkpp2dmnqlscGupaSdlGO1tbnL